Syndicated by: Suw Charman-Anderson| Author: Kevin Anderson

From the Twittersphere, Robert Andrews pointed me in the direction of this post by Martin Belam, Google hijacks traffic from newspaper site search. Martin as always makes some good arguments on why this might be a threat to newspapers.

Whilst Google has dressed this up as being for the benefit of users, it does have some significant implications of website traffic for the newspapers involved, and has the potential to dent their revenue. … By allowing people to do site searches whilst still on google.co.uk, Google is potentially reducing the number of page, and therefore advert, impressions that these newspapers may be getting. In fact, not only that, but Google is effectively hijacking the advertising that can be displayed by newspapers against search queries on their own site.

I agree that this might negatively impact newspapers’ revenue both in terms of display adverts and also when the newspapers themselves (including the folks that pay my wage, the Guardian) insert text adverts alongside their search results.

Where I might disagree is Martin’s argument that it negatively impacts user experience. He says that Google’s position is that they can provide search better than the news sites. Well, the sad truth is that whether it’s information architecture or search, most news organizations have been very slow to improve these parts of their services. Some news and media organizations have forced their users to use Google because their own search is unusable. They still are making the unmissable, unfindable.

I also see a number of newspapers forcing their users to follow a print paradigm that their drive-by readers may not be familiar with. I guess it’s useful for newspapers to allow people to filter their knowledge based on authors, section and branding. It’s useful for those people who are familiar with those things, but increasingly, I believe that many people coming to a site from some random link on the Internet aren’t familiar with those things and wouldn’t find that type of filtering useful and may find site architecture based on those considerations baffling. It’s sad that in 2008, we’re still building news sites for us and not our audiences. News editors can’t see the forest from the dead trees and build sites based on their print reading behaviors and their intimate knowledge of their desk structure instead of information needs of their audiences. When you look at online audiences for national or international titles, the great majority are not going to have any familiarity with your print product. Using print product paradigms as a basis for site architecture is a mistake.

Hey maybe I’m an edge case. Or maybe not. (Go to about 2:35 in the discussion of The State of the News Media 2008 by On the Media.) I only read physical newspapers when I fly. I rarely buy newspapers, and my news consumption is a lot more promiscuous. I don’t believe that any news source provides me with the complete picture so I fill in the blanks on my own. So, what do you think? Is Google hijacking newspaper website traffic?

Suw Charman-Anderson’s blog

Originally posted 2008-04-01 09:42:18. Republished by Old Post Promoter

• 30DC - Thirty Day Challenge Internet Marketing Recap Normally, I don't do extraordinarily long posts. But summing up 30dc aka thirty day challenge in 1 post is a mouthful. So I've formatted it nicely in an easy to read way with clickable links to the resources. Right upfront there's been much discussion about what sites to post content......
• More Website Traffic: 5 Surefire Tips If you have a website, then its lifeblood is traffic. If you are selling your own product, you need more website traffic to turn a percentage of visitors into buyers. If you are selling someone else’s product as an affiliate, you need to constantly increase website traffic to offset dwindling......
• Google's Big Thing Image via Wikipedia There's been a lot happening over at google and they've grown their partnership with Twitter since October 2009. If you don't know they're integrating tweets into a real time social search engine. It's speculated that results will be highly personalized and based on what your connections......
• Social Media Newspapers Social Media Newspapers - Top 7 Web 2.0 Tactics Used by Newspapers In the world of journalism many have predicted the farewell of the news world's most ubiquitous and iconic symbol – the newspaper. With the advent of the internet, blogs and social networking sites, more and more people are......
• Delicious Home Page - How This Google Wave Spam Site Did it Check out what I saw earlier today on Delicious.com. As you know bookmarking can get your site initially seen and indexed by the search engines. Some sites still do pass some link power to your sites as well but mostly the use of these social bookmarking services for seo link......

• Increase Blog Traffic Today, pt2 Here is part two in...
• 6 More Tips For Raising Your Search Engine Rankings Whether or not your web...
• How to Rank at First Page of Google in 3 Easy Steps - Rank at First Page of Google Guides A proper search engine optimization...
• Search Engine Basics Unfortunately obtaining your web site...
• Understanding the Simple SEO Structure From Title, to Meta, to Content Unfortunately I see so many...